I have been using a cover and reel since last fall, I can't imagine trying to gather and fold the cover over the edge. The reel is easy to use and move to the side for a quick swim.
I can remove/replace the cover in about 1 minute and never get in or wet, maybe sprinkled a bit. I think I would get quite wet trying to pull the cover over the edge, especially my feet, and could guess as much as 10 minutes to gather a bit here and move to the next spot, gather, then move, etc.
If I completely remove the cover I need a helper (teenage son) to carry one end to a shady spot.
I'm happy with my reel.
Steve
BTW, I have a nice, neat cutout for my steps. I moved the location of my steps and so rotated my reel around and discovered my round pool is about 3inches out of round! I'll have to reassemble the pole making in a bit longer.
Bookmarks