Thanks again PoolDoc. I fired the pool guy and hired the neighbors pool guy who has been doing their pool for 12 years and it looks great. Draining the water today. Will repaint with rubber based enamel since Im a middle of the road kind of guy. Neighbor says pool was just painted 3 or 4 years ago, my guess is with acrylic. The old water was so bad! I wasn't really planning on a big project like this but suspected it might be necessary when I bought the house. I guess this is what credit cards are for!