Looking to buy automatic pool cleaner 4 IG pool

[nater]

Hi ddawnwes,

Ultimately, only you can decide which kind fits your needs. You can search these forums for specific cleaner models to see what people think, then make a pro/con list.

Here are some of the things I thought about before buying my Dolphin robotic cleaner. I've never used one of the other types, so my experience is limited. Hopefully others will expand this list based on experience:

Robots:
Pros:
1). Low labor to use (carry it to the pool, unwind the cord, clean the bag, carry back to storage, etc)
2). They greatly improve water circulation
3). Cleans the sides and water line
4). Do a good job of "polishing" the water, they filter to a smaller particle size than my sand filter with DE added.
5). No extra wear and tear on pool pump, no booster pump needed, the stuff they pick up stays out of the filter.
Cons:
1). Expensive. (I was lucky and found a good deal during the off season on ebay)
2). Complex electronics and wear parts (brushes, drive belts, etc), give the potential for failure and repair expense.

Suction side cleaners:
Pros
1). Cheaper option
Cons:
1). Everything goes to the filter, more frequent backwashing, etc (not a big deal unless water is very expensive where you live)
2). More setup, tear down time when you want to swim
3). Won't clean sides or waterline (I'm starting to sound like an advertisement for robots )

Pressure side cleaners:
Cons: In addition to the list above, [edit] some may require [edit] a booster pump to operate.

People on this forum have had good luck with a device called "the Poolbuster". Its like a dirt devil for your pool. The prices have gone up quite a bit, and the Commercial model is roughly $300. They have a smaller, less powerful unit this year called "the Pool Broom". I may get that just to hit my steps and to pick up stray bugs, dirt that don't require a full cleaning.