Convert indoor Baquacil pool to salt water chlorination?

[PoolDoc]

I'm where I was, with off-gassing: I don't know.

However, if you can ventilate the room continuously, it should be fine. Alternatively, Chem_Geek reminded me that you can use sodium percarbonate, instead of chlorine. It's not as messy, but it will cost 2x as much.

Here are instructions (do NOT use the links! they go to Chinese sites now!):
http://piscines-apollo.com/docs/baqu...conversion.pdf

And, sources for percarbonate:
http://www.soapgoods.com/Sodium-Perc...te-p-1001.html
http://www.chemistrystore.com/cart.c...3&child=100581

I checked Amazon, but they do not currently sell any plain percarbonate . . . and you do NOT want a detergent!

[cchase009]

PoolDoc,

thanks for the info. From your post, should I assume sodium percarbonate will not have the off-gassing effect? I reviewed the procedures in the link - will there be anything to vacuum to waste? With the chlorine steps the instructions included vacuuming the bottom of the pool to waste. Will the sodium percarbonate clean the filter and the pipes?

Any side effects I should be aware of?

Thanks again.

Regards,

C. Chase

[PoolDoc]

Chem_Geek thinks not; I don't know for myself, but I trust his judgement and knowledge on that.

[chem geek]

It's not so much that there won't be any outgassing, but that whatever is outgassed won't be chlorinated by-products so are less likely to be harmful. Sodium percarbonate has hydrogen peroxide and generally it produces water when oxidizing other chemicals.

[cchase009]

Thanks Chem geek. Not only am I concerned with the toxicity to humans, I'm wondering what if anything it will do to the structure. Room is primarily covered in Drywall.

[PoolDoc]

Chlorine is DEFINITELY more of a problem for indoor structures than Baquacil. And, if you don't have continuous fresh air ventilation, the damage, especially to wiring, can be severe.

I have extensive experience with indoor commercial pools . . . and have chosen to stay away from that topic here, because most owners find the information we provide complex enough . . . but managing indoor chlorinated pools is MUCH more complicated, with much less certain results.

Honestly, the more you describe your situation, the more inclined I am to recommend that you STAY on Baquacil, as long as no one but your family uses it. (Baquacil is NOT an adequate sanitizer in a commercial environment). Baquacil can be used successfully long term, if you do two things:

1. Replace 1/3 to 1/2 of your pool water every 6 months of use.
2. Replace 100% of your filter media (sand or cartridge) every 12 months of use.

It does NOT sound like you have an enclosure that was properly designed for a pool room. You are likely to have problems regardless, especially if the pool room walls are exposed to winter temps. You should inspect for corrosion and wiring damage REGARDLESS. But, if you use chlorine, the lack of a properly designed enclosure may well become critical.

Sorry . . .

[cchase009]

Thanks PoolDoc. I was under the assumption the SWCG woulld keep the chlorine @ a very low level - is this not so? Would 1 -3 ppm be too much for an indoor pool? The pool store recommended those levels.

If I stay on Bacquacil, how do I get rid of the current condition? Drain and replace? If so, how do I go about clearing the pipes?

Regards,

C. Chase